Speaking with Christians often yields the idea of a personal experience as the basis of faith. It is very hard to argue against this kind of thing, and it is often presented as an alternative “proof” for Christianity. After all, so many Christians claim this type of experience, and so where there is smoke there must be fire. But it is very easy to have smoke without fire, and many poor proofs do not add up to one good one. I would contend that these experiences just constitute another piece of evidence, and that, like other evidence we have looked at in this book, we should consider this evidence objectively before being persuaded by it.
For almost 40 years I have been a Christian. For much of this time, I felt that as a woman,…
People often comment that science encourages rationality and questioning, but I’m not convinced. Of course the scientific process is deeply…
My basic argument can be summed up in five words: “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.” This phrase, popularised by Carl Sagan…
In my previous post I went through the Bible weighing it in terms of its credibility, and I skimmed through…
Somehow I became convinced that the bible was credible. Actually, it was systematic exposure from a young age to a…
I used to have other reasons (meta arguments, in the sense that they do not use the text of the Bible directly) for accepting the validity of the claims of the Bible. Ultimately they do not matter—for me, the whole thing falls apart with the lack of credibility of the Bible, taken on its own terms, rather than based on some meta-argument. In other words, the biblical text is itself not credible where it matters (discussed in Section 3). But people use these meta-arguments to establish the credibility of the Bible, regardless of how incredible the text is, so I wanted to look at a few of them, and one in particular, which is the continued existence of the Christian church. I do not intend to look at this rigorously, but rather to point out a way that might be helpful to understand this and to explore where this kind of thinking might get us.
Photo Thomas Bresson, CC BY 3.0., via Wikimedia Commons There was a quote in our order of service this week, by…
In this post I want to recall some conversations I’ve had with various people that made an impression in some…
I read a post on FB recently by the Archbishop of Canterbury, which went like this: “People often ask me…
